Elf Atochem North America, Inc. v. Jaffari
727 A.2d 286 (Del. 1999)
An LLC member sues in Delaware despite an agreement to arbitrate in California
- In one lineEn una línea
- The LLC agreement governs the members' rights, and its forum and arbitration clauses bind the members and the LLC even in a derivative suit.El operating agreement rige los derechos de los miembros y sus cláusulas de foro y arbitraje obligan a los miembros y a la LLC incluso en una acción derivada.
- RuleRegla
- Delaware's LLC Act gives maximum effect to freedom of contract; an LLC agreement's dispute-resolution provisions are enforceable against members and the entity, displacing the default statutory forum.
- Why this case is herePor qué está aquí este caso
- The LLC chapter's lesson that the operating agreement is king: members, and the LLC itself, are bound by what they contract.
- Procedural posturePostura procesal
- Elf sued Jaffari and the LLC derivatively in the Court of Chancery; the court dismissed for lack of subject matter jurisdiction under the agreement's arbitration and forum clause; the Delaware Supreme Court affirmed.
0:00
Say the answer out loud before revealing each part. Rate yourself honestly; the case comes back sooner when you miss.Di la respuesta en voz alta antes de revelar cada parte. Califícate con honestidad; el caso vuelve antes si fallas.
Panic kit: “Could you repeat the question, please?” · “Let me make sure I have the facts right: …” · “I'm not certain, but I'd argue … because …”Kit de pánico: “Could you repeat the question, please?” · “Let me make sure I have the facts right: …” · “I'm not certain, but I'd argue … because …”
How did it go?¿Cómo te fue?